Friday, July 11, 2003

Chilling out

It has been very hot in Oxford lately. Uncomfortably so at times. So it was with great relief that I finally managed to get myself into Edamame on sushi night. (Edamame keep wierd hours which have thwarted my previous attempts to eat there).

Believe me, when its hot like this there is nothing quite like fresh sushi, cold Ashahi beer in little frosted glasses and chilled Edamame beans. Thursday night is Sushi night at Edamame, I thoroughly recommend it.

Thursday, July 10, 2003

To the barricades!

In best Oxford tradition Queens college have just announced rent increases well over the rate of inflation, at the time of year when the students are least well placed to respond. (its summer, and most people are elsewhere). As an undergraduate I was heavily involved in trying to organise rent strikes, demonstrations and other such resistance. Its worth pointing out that it only came to such desperate measures because the college in question (LMH) was extremely reluctant to explain how it worked out its numbers, what else it had considered and so on.

Hopefully Queens will be more accomodating. All I want to see is the business case they've got for these increases and an explanation as to why nothing else they've considered (like cutting costs or raising new funds or selling stuff) is appropriate.

Failing that I guess we'll just have to protest. And I'll be doing it for you kids, since I'll never actually pay any of these new prices. (I've paid my last rent cheque, these are for next year)

Wednesday, July 09, 2003

SBP picks up steam

Phase one of our SBP is essentially a benchmarking exercise. That means conducting a lot of interviews, and giving people marks across a whole range of criteria. (24 according to the sheet in front of me). We've now finished our first two interviews and we've got another ten in the pipeline. We're targetting 30, so I think we're more or less on track for now.

We're also getting used to Cisco's welter of IT infrastructure. They are very very wired indeed, with everything conducted via outlook exchange, instant messaging services and a few more esoteric bits of kit. The techie in me likes to see this lot in action, the pragmatist is yet to be convinced of it's value.

Monday, July 07, 2003

Job hunt begins in earnest

A month ago I trawled monster.com for marketing jobs and found *none* that were interesting. Yesterday I turned up ten in the right salary / responsibility bracket, and two were ones that really got my attention. I'd reckon that most of the jobs I'm looking at are long shots - 10-1 or worse odds, but those are winnable odds.

I'm also of the opinion that companies find jobs for people who impress them. So even if organisation x decides I'm not the man for the top job I may get offered something else - perhaps with a view to later promotion. Either way its a good way to go at the market.

All I want is a brand, you know, one to look after and call my own. One I can take over the world with. That kind of thing.

Opening thoughts on summer projects

So what's an SBP like? Well so far the summer business project with Cisco has been a lot like doing a consulting job, but with extra academic theory and a less punishing schedule. My groups in favour of a steady 9-5 schedule (or 10-6 when we have to commute to London) and that's working out well.

Can't say too much about the details of the project, but so far it's been pretty interesting and it's an interesting return to the world of work.

Wednesday, July 02, 2003

Summer Plans

As well as putting in eight weeks of effort for Cisco over the summer there's a whole load of stuff I've got to be getting on with. Here's a summary.

Find a job - I keep putting this off, but I can't put it off much longer
Visit Cornwall for a weekend
Visit the Lake district for a weekend
Read Harry Potter
Learn options - never got them straight in my head, won't feel right till I do
Help the business school with their website
Get back into the habit of going to the gym on a regular basis
Design next years blog

I'm sure there's much much more, but that'll do for a start.

Monday, June 30, 2003

Cisco Day One

Day one of the Cisco Summer Business Project today. I'm not sure how much I can reasonably say about the project, so you're going to have to make do with generalities from here. It went well, Cisco were helpful and provided us with laptops and full employee access to their system.

Their system is very impressive, and really rather large.

Bit like the company really.

Sunday, June 29, 2003

Balls

Keble ball was fun, although for those not used to Oxford balls the comment was more 'this is more like a fair for grown ups than a ball' which is fair enough. There was a bouncy castle, there was a ferris wheel, there was a coconut shy. There was also (and I have no explanation for this) a table of plates which people were invited to smash by throwing cricket balls at them.

Now I don't know why this was going on, but it kept several undergraduates occupied for many many hours. They started at 9 and were still going when we left at 2:30 in the morning. Perhaps this was a last minute strategy adopted by the organisers when they realised that a number of clinically insane guests had arrived, or perhaps this is what today's kids do in their spare time - I have no idea.

Plate smashing, it's the next big thing.

Friday, June 27, 2003

Exam surivived

Done and dusted. One hour of Global Comparative Business later and the prevailing thought among the class is 'what was all the fuss about'. I wrote good stuff on the IMF and a general 'what is globalisation' question. I was less convincing on the differences between the GATT and the WTO, but it was good enough.

Time to relax, and tonight, time to party. We've got a drinks reception at the school, a class photo and then a cruise down the river to look forward to. Tomorrow is Keble ball which the MBA class have adopted as their end of term party - about 60 of us are going.

Todays Required Linking

Read this. Then go here.

If this turns out to be illegal something is seriously wrong.

Thursday, June 26, 2003

That'll do for now

I started this at 4 o'clock. It's now nearly ten o'clock and five and a half hours is enough for anyone. If anyone's just reaching this blog here's a brief explanation of what's been going on.

I have an exam tomorrow, for which I was underprepared. I've just written up revision notes for six of the eight weeks of the course online, as blog entries. A quick cut and paste into word reveals almost 5000 words worth of effort. If you read the archives they'll make sense if you start here and work up.

Thank you and goodnight.
Back once again with the online revision. We're up to...

Week 6 : Foreign Direct Investment

Questions to think about for this are

What is the difference between ‘direct’ and ‘indirect’ expropriation and how has the latter been interpreted in recent international investment disputes?
What are international investment treaties and do they matter?

Now I'm not planning on writing any essays on this so what follows is intended to get me marks on one of the short questions I may have to cover on this.

FDI has been growing rapidly lately, about 20% a year since 1980. All kinds of reasons for this, developed countries like being invested in as it's good for unemployment. Developing countries like being invested in as it's good for exports. The opening of the Soviet bloc has also created a load of opportunites for firms who want to invest in educated cheap labour, previously untapped natural resources or just to be near the end market in some very large countries. (Poland is a very big place you know)

There's also what I'm going to call Japanese Car Syndrome. Namely foreign firms tend to be more productive than domestic ones, so you can learn a lot from them.

On the supply side firms have started investing overseas to avoid country of origin clauses, to make use of JIT techniques or to exploit foreign labour (sometimes in a good way). Most FDI has gone to developed countries though, France is much more likely to be investing in Germany or America than it is in Pakistan or Bangladesh. This is partly because the statistics include mergers and large stakeholdings.

How is FDI regulated? Badly is the short answer. There's nothing like the WTO and while direct expropriation (sorry, that's my oil well now, thank's for building it) hasn't happened much lately indirect expropriation (thanks for investing, have you seen next years tax rates / minimum wages) is still a problem.

It hasn't been possible to create something for international investment because there is a lot of entrenched opposition. From labour unions, NGO's, domestic monopolies / oligopolies and NGO's. There are some frameworks though, including Chapter 11 of NAFTA and the Single European Market. WTO members can also agree things called GAT's between themselves,. in NAFTA the equivalent is a BIT (Bilateral Trade Agreement)

It's worth knowing about BITs and GATs cause they work in different directions. A BIT agrees to liberalise everything except named exceptions. A GAT agrees to liberalise only those things it mentions.

Disputes over investment treaties / investments can be settled either through state - state discussion or state - investor discussion. The Ethyl Corporation provides an example of how this works. Ethyl wanted to import MMT (a fuel additive) into Canada. Canada banned the import on health grounds, but didn't ban domestic production. Not surprisingly Ethyl sued for effectice expropriation and Canada both settled and reversed the ban.

Some have seen this as trade treaties overturning good environmental legislation. In this case it's more like trade treaties overturning cack handed Canadian protectionism. If they'd banned it properly and had enough evidence it was bad for your health they'd have been fine.


Now for part II of our exciting look at the Washington Consensus

Week 5 : The Washington Consensus in Action

After seeing off the Latin American crisis the IMF was armed with a new ideology and a one size fits all solution to future crises. In retrospect this should have been alarming, but convergence was the order of the day - if all economies could be made like those of the capitalist west we'd be fine. Sadly the IMF was then presented with a succession of opportunities to demonstrate how not to do it in Russia, East Asia and Africa. I'm going to focus on East Asia here...

In 1997 the Thai Baht was hit by currency speculation and it collapsed. Fear of contagion saw neighbouring currencies start to go the same way as hot money made a 'flight to quality'. (sell Baht, buy $$$). Once again there was the danger that countries with weak currencies would not be able to meet their debts to the west. Enter the IMF.

IMF treatment consisted of short term loans tied to implementation of the Washington Consesus. Governments were told to cut spending and raise taxes. In Indonesia a requirement to cut spending on welfare payments sparked riots and led to deaths - that was reversed shortly afterwards but the cut in investment had long term consequences for the economy.

The IMF considered that it had 'all areas' access to creditor states policy and told the Koreans to dismantle excess capacity in their semi-conductor industry. The Koreans refused arguing that the downturn in semi-conductors was cyclical. Quite why the IMF thought they knew more about the semi-conductor industry than the Koreans is open to debate, in any event the Koreans were proved right and their semi-conductor industry proved vital in leading them out of recession.

Elsewhere the IMF demanded market liberalisation and an end to anything that looked like capital controls. Malaysia refused to go along with this and came through the crisis much better than anywhere else. In Korea long term investment barely dropped despite the crisis, all the damage was being done by 'hot money', capital controls may have forced investors to keep their money wwhere it was and seen off the crisis. This was exactly the kind of thing Keynes had intended when the IMF was set up, but to todays IMF it's anathema.

In Korea problems were caused by market liberalisation. Korea had been pushed into opening it's markets to global capital before they were ready to deal with it. Hence all the problems with Korean banks not being up to scratch and the resulting crisis of confidence. Had the policy been to open Korea up gradually and introduce banking reform / strong institutions as they went this mess might have been avoidable.

The response to this and other problems with the Washington Consensus has been as follows.

1. Sequencing - you have to do things in the right order. Such as not privatising state monopolies before you've got rules to regulate them (Russia)
2. Capital Account Liberalisation - now this should only be attempted in the presence of strong institutions
3. Soverign Debt Workout - a proposal that the IMF should be able to sit down with govts and creditors to restructure their debt. Oddly enough commercial interests are blocking this one.
4. Capital controls - suggestions that these might work after all have sparked *open disagreement* (unheard of in the IMF)
5. Don't mess with what you don't understand - IMF turned out to make a lousy aid agency in Africa

Stiglitz suggests that the culture of the IMF as an institution may be as much at fault as it's economics. IMF economists are not specialists on the countries they're sent to. Rather they're despatched to solve crises at short notice and arrive bearing a briefcase of standard prescriptions. The prevailing attitude is that if the problem state was any good at economics it wouldn't be in the mess it is.

It's worth mentioning what the world bank was doing during all of this. In Africa it's had a much better record since it stopped lending to dictators. In Russia it ran into problems because although it had plenty of money to lend Russia Russia was not well set up to spend it. Russia already had schools, universities, roads and factories and didn't really need more. It also had hyperinflation, inadequate institutions and a massive insurgence of organised crime, but the bank couldn't do much about that. In Asia the bank got caught up in the IMF lending to sustain the currencies that were under pressure from speculators. The immediate result was that the bank, IMF and assorted governments discovered that speculators have an incredible amount of money and can suck up as much as the bank can give out.

Week 4 : The Rise of the Washington Consensus

I'm not going to write too much about this as I'm reasonably confident I can remember this bit, partly because I went and saw Joseph Stiglitz lecture on it, and partly because its something that interests me. Plus it's easy to take up highly opinionated positions which makes life a lot easier. Anyway...

As you may remember from an earlier post in 1982 Mexico nearly went bankrupt in response to high US interest rates and a fall in world trade. This was swiftly followed by similar problems in Brazil and other latin american countries. These states were characterised by poorly performing industry, high levels of debt and governments that had adopted loose monetary policy as a means of postponing difficult decisions. Inflation was rife and no-one had cash to pay the banks.

Many of the banks were in America.

Since the currencies of the Latin American states were under massive pressure this was a job for the IMF. It duly did it's job providing substantial bail outs in exchange for promises of reform from its new debtors. These promises were...

1. Cut government spending
2. Reduce subsidies to domestic industries
3. Broaden the tax base and spend on health, education and infrastructure
4. Raise interest rates
5. Achieve competitive exchange rates

For nations in this position this is reasonably sound advice. However the short term shocks were unpleasant with unemployment soaring and economies entering depression as currency devalution meant firms could not pay back debt in dollars. There were demonstrations against all the governments involved. Almost all the costs were born by the debtor nations, not a single US bank reduced dividends as a result of this. This is despite the fact that the banks new full well how risky these loans had been at the time.

In effect the IMF had bailed out the US banks who's willingness to lend was at least part of the problem. By 1985 it was clear that while these countries weren't in trouble anymore they weren't exactly performing either. Thus another five points were added to the plan, these were cunningly named Phase II : Adjustment for Growth

1. Liberalise trade and minimise tarriffs
2. Encourage FDI
3. Privatise everything that isn't nailed down to improve efficiency
4. Deregulate the economy to stop corrupt / bureaucratic govt inefficiency
5. Enforce property rights

If you think this looks a lot like Reaganite / Thatcherite economics you're right. Although these poor countries saw their trade and tarriffs liberalised a hell of a lot more than we did.

The result of this lot was to put Mexico back on the road to growth, now as a satelite state of the USA. Since joining NAFTA 90% of Mexican trade is with the US, prior to the crisis it had a far broader export base and was a leader among developing nations. Now it's middle classes have been obliterated and there's a lot of ground to make up.

Interestingly the IMF bail out allowed the western banks to shift the debts they'd racked up off their books (the IMF effectively paid them off) but the nations the IMF lent money to are still in debt. The financial community introduced reforms with the Basle I agreement that should prevent them doing the same thing again.
Welcome back to the online revision session. And now for...

Odds and sods about trade

A few things worth mentioning about trade are...

1. In the Uruguay round of GATT the west managed to push for the introduction of trade in services. This was great for them, since it meant they could export the work of their consultants, ad agencies, engineers and so on more easily. It was less good for the developing nations since by and large they don't export services. India may yet have the last laugh on this one though since they're getting very good indeed at IT consultancy.

2. In the 1980's the US imposed 'voluntary quotas' on the Japanese. Since these were voluntary they lay outside the scope of the GATT but by forcing the Japanese not to import more than a certain number of cars they effectively protected the US auto industry. Sort of. The Japanese aren't dumb and promptly went from producing mid range mass market cars to expensive luxury ones (which sell in smaller numbers) and took the most valuable sector of the market away from Detroit.

3. Even within the EU regulations which ostensibly have nothing to do with protectionism form effective barriers. Differing legislation on safety standards has been damaging the efficiency of the automobile industry for decades.

It's getting hot in here

So hot that I'm now revising with my shirt off. Have to put it back on now though, time to go and get some food.

When I return look forward to more on trade and a potted history of the Washington consensus.

Thank god for that

Jeff Pittman, future nobel laureate and current student has just sent me his frameworks for this. As every MBA student and Management Consultant knows you can't go wrong with a good framework.

Fear me exam, for I have a diagram!

Second one looks must more impressive. Right, back to week three.
Welcome to the online revision session. Can I pass Global Coparative Business in a single night?

Week Three : International Trade / GATT and the WTO


For this our questions are...

What were the main consequences for businesses of the Uruguay Round of the GATT?
Does the WTO enforce ‘free trade’?

OK. I don't remember this lecture at all. Not even a little bit. Wonder if I was there.

GATT was set up in 1947 as a temporary measure. One of it's chief goals was to facilitate the reduction of US tarriffs which were up to 100% on somce products and to keep tarriffs low thereafter. There were 23 founding members including such economic giants as Ceylon, Burma, Southern Rhodesia, Luxemburg, the Lebanon and France. Membership fluctuated (in 1949 it was down to 13 countries) but the trend was up. By the Uruguay round (86-94) there were 123 countries.

The basic rules of the GATT are as follows.

1. If you give one member country a break on tarriffs you give all member countries a break on tarriffs.
2. Once it's in your country you have to treat it like any other widget.

This last one is a problem since it makes it impossible to discriminate between dolphin / turtle friendly tuna and non-friendly tuna since according to the rules they're identical product. It's also worth noting that until 2001 when it joined the WTO China's MFN deal with the USA meant the US treated it as a member even though it wasn't.

Free trade or fair? There's a big difference between free trade and fair trade. With free trade things like dumping surpluses on foreign markets, states subsidising domestic industries and so on would be fine. Since the GATT and WTO try to stop this they're more interested in fair trade. But this tends to be fair to big nations with deep pockets.

Article 20 This is the bit that says when you can ignore the rules, and that's basically in time of emergency - to protect lives or the environment. It's the clause that's been used to break patents on AID's drugs. There are a few more get outs for developing countries as well - you can avoid playing by the rules if you've got a balance of payments crisis and you get much longer to implement tarriff reductions.

Importantly GATT doesn't rule out regional trade agreements, so NAFTA and the EU can lower tarriffs internally all they want without having to open the market to the rest of the WTO.

Dispute settlement in the WTO So you've caught Ruritania dumping Ruritanian Marshmallows onto your Ebonian Marshmallow Market, what can you do? Well first you've got to try and reach an agreement with Ruritania. If that fails things go to a panel of lawyers and judges. If you don't like the judges verdict you can go to the Appelate Body and what they say goes. Sadly at this stage there is no automatic punishment, but you are allowed to inflict your own.

Basically if you have a judgement in your favour you can start taxing the imports of the person who upset you as much as you like. This is supposed to go on a carousel method whereby you target their industries in turn. This is fine among nations of similar size, but imagine Bermuda trying to punish America like this - it's not going to work.

That said WTO rulings do tend to get stuck to, especially by the big powers. So far it's been remarkably robust.

Welcome to the online real time revision session

Week Two : Globalisation and it's causes


Sample questions for this week include

1. Is ‘globalization’ different from ‘international economic interdependence’?
2. What causes globalization?
3. Globalize or globalise?

OK, the basic argument here is between those who say that globalisation is nothing new and that we had similar levels of international trade in 1913, (33% of world GDP was trade before WWI buggered everything up) and those who say that a) actually we have got more and b)what we've got is qualitatively different in that it implies much deeper and more complex relationships between states and organisations.

Part of this argument is based around notions of convergence toward a single economic model. The argument says that one day we'll all be like America. Communism failed, European Social Democracy is in financial bother and anyone who wants to have a half way successful economy had better get with the program. Now I didn't do three years of history to fall for this kind of telelogical garbage. People said much the same about Japan in the 80's, Asia in the (pre crisis) 90's and Soviet Russia in the 50's. Anyway, China is too damn big and too damn different for this stuff to hold true.

Now for some figures. Outward Foreign Direct Investment by the USA in 2000 was $1.2trn, little old UK managed $900bn so we're not that far back. France and Germany clock up $500bn and $450bn respectively. This represents a six fold increase for the USA since 1980, but a tenfold one for the UK. For France its about twenty times what it was - for Germany its ten times. To put it another way we're all at it - at least all of us in the west (+Japan).

Here's a scary figure for proponents of US Hegemony. Since 1980 China's share of world production has gone from 3.4 to 12%. The US's share has been a stable 21%. The scary thing is they've only industrialised a fraction of their country. Other useful stats on how real this all is include the fact that 1/3rd of all international trade is intra-firm, that is multinational firms shipping stuff around inside their own organisations. A further 1/3rd is multinational firms selling stuff to each other.

On the other hand, globalisation isn't just about trade. It's about governing on a global scale. Responses to environmental pollution, terrorism, the drugs trade (which is equal to 8% of global trade) and arms dealing (80% of weapons are illegally held) all need to be global in nature. Forums for global government are starting to emerge and as the things that need governing go on getting global we either set up some kind of world government or get buried by them. That's probably over the top but states can no longer do this kind of thing by themselves. That said regionalism may be enough what with NAFTA and the EU.

Works for football doesn't it? You've got CONCACAF, UEFA and all the rest overseen by FIFA. Just a thought.

According to the lecture notes globalisation is caused either by technology, the increased cost of protectionism or the triumph of US neo-conservative ideology. We can probably disregard the last one as a short term blip. Technology has made communication cheaper and the global financial markets couldn't operate the way they do without it. Simply put crises develop too quickly and on too massive a scale for anyone to do anything about it. The costs of staying out argument is more convincing when you see that freight costs are down 70% since the 1970's. The explosion of foreign investment also makes been open to it much more attractive. (However China still regulates FDI heavily - manages to get a lot though)
Welcome to the online real time revision session

Reasons to be cheerful


One : I went to all but one of the lectures
Two : I went to all Stiglitz' lectures when he visited
Three : I can always resort to babbling about Marxism just like when I was an undergraduate

hmm, only two reasons then
Welcome to the online real time revision session

Week One : Introduction to International Political Economy

Big shout out to Andreas Rother for his excellent revision notes. Share and share alike all you b-school people.

Right, following WWII a three legged system was set up to prevent a repeat of the great depression. The three legs were trade, exhange rates and money. Each was the domain of a specific institution. The system was created at the Bretton Woods conference and much of it was the brainchild of John Meynard Keynes. This is important because it means the entire system is predicated on Keynesian lines, namely markets are not efficient and concerted government action at the macro level is needed to correct / prevent market failures.

The GATT was not what was originally planned. Keynes had wanted an international board of trade, but this was watered down to a treaty by the US congress. The GATT never got to be more than a rich man's club with 50 members at its peak and high criteria required for any state joining. GATT never included anything about agriculture which had terrible consequences for the third world.

The IMF was set up to manage a set of fixed exchange rates. A global system of currency pegs was meant to ensure stability. If a country developed a short term balance of payments problem the IMF could intervene with emergency loans. In exchange for these loans the IMF could impose conditions intended to prevent the problem recurring.

The World Bank started life as the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development which could raise money cheaply due to it's excellent credit rating and use this money to finance the projects needed to rebuild Europe. It was effectively one big Keynesian investment vehicle intended to inflate economies by injecting investment. In the event it didn't do much in Europe as fear of democratic communism saw the Marshall plan introduced. For want of something else to do the World Bank turned its attention to the developing world.

Changes to the system
As ever events conspired to send the plans of the great and good astray. The cold war led to the institutions listed above being pushed into the front line to defend capitalism. The World Bank and IMF ended up making loans to third world dictatorships to prevent them turning to the soviet bloc. No-one seriously expected this money to end up anywhere other than in swiss bank accounts and the pockets of arms dealers. Such 'odious debt' is now contentious - surely we can't expect people to repay this?

More importantly by the end of the 1960's Vietnam and Johnson's social policies which had been financed by printing money meant the USA could no longer stay inside the fixed currency regime and in 1971 the US suspended convertibility. In 1973 OPEC delivered the mother of all supply side shocks to the western economy and things were looking rough. Industrialised nations led a round of 'new protectionism' as tarriffs were raised and exclusive deals like the Multi-Fibre Agreement (no cheap cotton here thankyou) were signed.

Realising that this was going to be very bad for them indeed the developing world tried to form something called the New International Economic Order, but this effort failed.

By the early 80's the GATT was in ruins, the IMF redundant and the world bank tainted by association with dubious regimes. Then Mexico nearly went bankrupt and everything changed again...

In 1982 Mexico was hit by the US decision to raise interest rates. Trade collapsed and US banks realised that Mexico was about to default on a lot of debt - potentially triggering a global financial crisis. The IMF intervened with a big bail out and imposed strict controls on Mexico. This and future interventions in Brazil and other countries saw the emergence of the Washington Consensus. (see future notes on week 4)

In the 1990's the Washington Consensus which had worked well (ok, maybe just worked) in Latin America was applied to Russia, East Asia and Africa. It didn't work.

In 1995 the GATT was incorporated into the much bigger and much more pluralist Word Trade Organisation. This has much broader membership and is better for developing countries (see future notes on week 3)

Triage

Ed Yourdon's one word advice for project management is going to be handy here.

What we're trying to learn

Here's the rubric from the reading list.

Globalization describes a transformation in the world economy. As economies become more interdependent and more sensitive to global markets, governments and corporations face a wider and more complex set of opportunities and challenges. This course investigates the phenomenon of globalization, its impact and the choices and dilemmas posed for governance at the level of the corporation, the government and the world economy. The approach and method of the course is international political economy—a branch of international relations which applies the tools of political science and economic theories of institutions to explain what drives and explains events in the world economy. Throughout the course there is an alternating attention given to industrialized economies and relations among them, and to emerging market and developing economies and their role and prospects in the global economy.

This course, unlike many other business school courses on international business, does not concern itself with the internal administration of the multinational enterprise. It focuses instead on the external institutional, regulatory and political environment in which firms conduct their business across national borders. The course begins with an introduction to international political economy, the core questions it addresses in respect of globalization and the tools of analysis deployed to answer those questions. Week 2 then looks specifically at globalization: what it is, what drives globalization, and what this means practically for trade, finance and public policy in the world economy. Week 3 focuses on the issue of international trade and explores how governments and other interested groups negotiate trade rules and the opening up of trade markets and with what implications. Weeks 4 and 5 examine the pressures and problems for policy convergence in a globalizing world economy, shifting the focus of the course to the emerging and developing economies. In particular, the rise of the Washington consensus is charted and its impact on several economies is explored in week 4 and in a sequel lecture in week 5 the rewriting or demise of the Washington consensus is examined. In week 6 the course turns to examine investment and the politics, trends and regulatory environment within which global investors operate. Week 7 explores in greater detail the particular impact and challenges raised for corporations by NGOs and the new ‘Global civil society’ revolution. In the final week of the course global economic governance and accountability are examined along with the implications of current ideas for reforming the management of the world economy.

That's what we've got to get through. I've decided to skip the stuff on NGO's as we did a lot of that in Corporate Responsibility and I can bluff my way through a short question on it. Stuff I need to learn includes the latin American crises in the 80's, the structure of the WTO, World Bank and IMF. I've also decided to brush up on Foreign Direct Investment.

Public revision experiment

OK, I've got an exam tomorrow on Global Comparitive Business, but a combination of coursework, apathy, Summer Project distractions and assorted online gubbins has distracted me to the point that I am now in something approaching trouble. Why? because I haven't done enough revision.

Therefore I will be revising online, all night or at least until my will power gives out. If I pass (and we won't find out for a month or so) you can assume that everything you need to know on the subject is here. OK?

Wednesday, June 25, 2003

Are you a future student?

By my reckoning about 10% of next years MBA class have found their way to this site and sent me an email. If you are part of that class or know anyone who is please point them in this direction, I'm happy to answer questions.

I'm also trying to improve the quality of the information which reaches people before they get here and have floated a few ideas with the schools admin. If you've got thoughts on this, can point me to some best practice elsewhere or anything else let me know. To get in touch just click this link

Delayed blogging

I forgot to link to this magnificent comic when I found it. Check out the Crab City Series from Goats.com . Here's a sample

"I'm on a case, Knowledgeable Pete. The kind of case that takes your very soul and puts it in a tiny box and then puts a hamster on top of that box. And that hamster never moves, Pete. The hamster never moves again."

Tuesday, June 24, 2003

Crisis Averted

4950 words later, (plus footnotes) and I've got my leadership essay ready to hand in. That leaves tonight or tomorrow (probably tonight) to sort out the groupwork and then two whole days to revise. It's not a huge amount of time, but it's not nothing either.

If anyone feels advertising withdrawl

Here's a little gimmick that shows the adverts which Google would serve here if I carried advertising via their blogspot hosting services.

Click for Adverts

Pretty accurate huh? Link courtesy of Adsense

First ever essay crisis

Essay crises are traditional for Oxford undergraduates. Indeed the ability to knock out 2000 words on any subject in less than three hours, starting at two in the morning and having done no preparation is one of the main qualifications for studying here. Showing a woeful disregard for tradition I got through my entire undergraduate period without ever having one of these.

I may be catching up for lost time this week. A big old piece on leadership to write, a group essay to assemble and an exam to revise for. Global and Comparative business is the course that deals with stuff like the IMF and World Bank. It's one of the most interesting courses I've been to, and now it's going to be the one I'm least well prepared for come exams.

Sunday, June 22, 2003

More from Baghdad

What do you do when you are in a car with someone who asks you about the best place to hide a hand grenade? With reality crashing in through the windows Salaam Pax doesn't have much time for US policy these days.

Personally I'm surprised the whole having his street shelled by a US tank didn't radicalise him more.

Friday, June 20, 2003

The last lecture

I'm currently in the last lecture I expect to take as an MBA student. It's on leadership, leaderless groups and Al-Quaeda. Its odd to think that I've now been taught pretty much everything I'm going to be taught. From now on, I teach myself and learn from others. A week of exams (well one exam) assignment writing, an eight week project, then the final exams and I'm finished.

Its a very odd feeling. The real world is suddenly feeling very close indeed.

Wednesday, June 18, 2003

Beckham sold for £25m?

Following my how not to negotiate post (below) you could be excused for thinking that I might be a little embarrassed that Man Utd got £25m for Beckham after all. However as ever in the crazy world of football finance all is not as it seems. The headline figure is £25m but this is split into two chunks, part compulsary and part dependent on performance in the champions league.

So, its a £18m deal with a £7m bonus clause. Furthermore the £18m is spread over four years - with about £7m coming in here. The Guardian has the lowdown on all this.

Now this isn't all bad news, Man U will have no problem borrowing against their future income. But if we imagine the deal is being paid in five equal chunks with two of them coming together at the start and you discount at 10% the actual value is...

Year 1 : 7.2m
Year 2 : 3.24m
Year 3 : 2.98m
Year 4 : 2.7m

Or about £16m plus the possible bonus'. Wonder what's going to happen to the share price when the markets open.

If you're wondering why I've developed this sudden obsession with Beckham it's not because I'm a Man U fan - quite the opposite. It's because I've just finished a project on Beckham as a brand, how you might value him and what he might be worth. I suspect that Real have got a bargain, but that's all going to depend on the clauses about using the Beckham image rather than whether he's a £25m footballer. (he's certainly a £16m one)

Skeletons in closets

Or Arabs in cages, its all the same. Lock someone away long enough and even the world's media stops caring. Remember when this was front page news? No-one from CNN or Fox is covering this one. Once upon a time finding out what was going on in Guatanamo bay was all the news cared about - now its old hat.

I actually supported the war in Afghanistan (unlike the one in Iraq) but I sure don't support this.

Tuesday, June 17, 2003

Meanwhile on the other side of the world

LT-Smash is somewhere in a desert in Iraq, although from some of his recent posts he seems to have moved nearer to civilisation lately. I think he's bored.

He's also been thinking, which is interesting cause it gives the rest of us the chance to see what's going on inside a US soldiers head. As far as this US soldier goes it seems to be pretty sophisticated.

How not to negotiate

As the Beckham transfer saga drags on one thing is becoming clear. Manchester United are going to get far less than they could have done had they negotiated right. A few months ago a figure of £38m was doing the rounds as Beckham's likely price. This was the price Real Madrid would have to pay to get Manchester United to release a star player they were committed to keeping.

However Manchester United were not planning on keeping Beckham. Since extending his contract which expires in two years would entail handing out a multi-million pay rise and involve a signing fee that wasn't an option. Especially if Beckham wants to leave himself, letting his contract expire makes him a free agent and he could effectively name his price in the transfer market so instead of paying Manchester United £38m Madrid or someone else would have found themselves paying a healthy share of that money direct to Beckham. Much as they did when they signed Steve McMannaman from Liverpool as a free agent.

Things went wrong when Man U accepted a bid from Barcelona of £25m. Now they must have known that David Beckham was not about to move to Barcelona, since they're not in the Champions League and this season they failed to mount a half way serious challenge for the Spanish title. Not a suitable destination for the world's most glamourous footballer. Accepting the bid made it possible for Beckham to announce that he felt betrayed and make his eventual exit inevitable.

In theory other bidders like Milan or Juventus should be willing to bid, but it seems that either a lack of funds or the fact that they simply don't want Beckham means they're not going to. Madrid are now in the enviable position of being able to force the price down to rock bottom levels - knowing that Manchester will have to accept it. So from £38m to £25m to an eventual fee of £15m plus a player or two? Its probably even worse than this since transfer fees tend to be over-reported and paid in installments, the real value of the transfer could end up being very small indeed.

Now that's good business

Today's brand strategy class included some information about an absolutely fantastic project undertaken by Hindustan Lever Ltd, the Indian arm of Unilever. Most of the information is summarised here, but I love the way the company went out and created a market by doing things differently and exploiting the way things were rather than throwing their hands up and saying 'there is no decent distribution system for Indian villages, lets stick to the cities.'

When I grow up I want to do stuff like this.

Arghh doublethink

I'm not sure my head can cope with this. Rewriting history while accusing others of doing the same. One day someone will write a fantastic book about how the truth about the war (whatever that was) was negotiated between the media, politicians, armies, pressure groups and governments.

Sunday, June 15, 2003

Future plans

Over the summer I plan to come up with a design for whatever the next blog will be which should keep me occupied. In the meantime I'll just have to feel bad that my skills don't extend to producing animation as good as this

Samurai Lapin
Parts 2 and 3.

Yes, that's rabbit in French.

Saturday, June 14, 2003

Ain't no free riding in this town

Free riding is the phenomenon whereby someone in a study group doesn't pull their weight, and as I understand it it happens at pretty much every business school. The only way to deal with it is for the students who are on the recieving end to get stroppy and cause problems. The ultimate sanction of taking someones' name off a piece of work is so drastic no one ever uses it.

Following a discussion with the course director (who is an economist and felt that some kind of market mechanism would be sufficient to fix this) Maria and I came up with the following :-

At the end of each term (but before any marks are known) all studygroup members submit anonymous marks out of 10 for each of their study group colleagues.

Those students in the bottom 20% are then formed into studygroups by themselves with the normal process being applied to everyone else.

You could set a minimum score for avoiding this, so if the whole class performs well no one need suffer.

The incentive would be to contribute as otherwise next term you would be guaranteed to find yourself in a group of unco-operative free riders. Worse, while it might not be announced which group is which the class is pretty quickly going to work out who comprise the 'plague ship' making finding NBD and SBP teams difficult for them.

Good news is that this proposal is going forward for consideration in some form and may be applied to next years students. If anyone knows of any similar systems at other business schools or has comments on this idea I'd love to hear about them.

Friday, June 13, 2003

Made me laugh

Well the job offers are starting to come in for folks here at SBS. I'm not saying the markets easy or anything but there are definitely more people who know where they're going and what they're doing than before. Of course that doesn't include me...

So I've decided to try this.

To Whom It May Concern:

Thank you for your letter of [date of the rejection letter]. After
careful consideration, I regret to inform you that I am unable to accept
your refusal to offer me employment at this time.

This year I have been particularly fortunate in receiving an unusually
large number of rejection letters. With such a varied and promising
field of candidates, it is impossible for me to accept all refusals.

Despite [Name of the Company]'s outstanding qualifications and previous
experience in rejecting applicants, I find that your rejection does not
meet with my current needs.

Therefore, I will initiate employment with your firm immediately. I
look forward to working with you. Best of luck in rejecting future
candidates.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

Tuesday, June 10, 2003

Places to be

Tim is at a very interesting conference in Boston about blogs and what they can and can't do, and a bunch of other stuff I'm sure. Wish I was, work here is starting to drive me nuts, although a half hour of sending email and trying to organise seems to have seen off lunchtimes massive frustration attack.

One big effort over the weekend and the end will be in sight I think. Oh, and the idea to try and set up some blog related thingumy for next years class seems to be a goer. Might take a little longer than I thought though. Important point is one Tim makes on his blog, if the school does this it can't control it. You only have to see the strings once and a puppet show will never look the same again.

Finally, Tony has mailed to say that the Oxford brand is playing much better for him in the US than it idid in Europe. Which is nice.

Monday, June 09, 2003

More Baghdad Blogs

G, of dear Raed fame now has a blog of his own. Wonder if the Guardian are going to give him a column too?

Bursting the blogobubble (version 0.1)

Aside from being the kind of right wing whiner who makes me come out all revolutionary Instapundit (better known as Glenn Reynolds) is very very very wrong about blogs. He, along with a few others are quietly crowing that it was their blogs which led to the resignation of Howell Raines at the NY Times.

Now much as I'd like to think I could knock out a few killer headlines and demolish Piers Morgan, Kelvin Mckensie and proably the uber editor Murdoch himself I'm pretty sure I can't. I'm pretty sure this didn't happen to Raines either, especially as the story that did for him began as an exclusive produced by a freelance journalist. Now, the story linked above has a few interesting elements that point to why weblogs aren't about to revolutionise anything... The reporter was a professional, paid to write and paid to research, he checked his facts and conducted interviews. More importantly he's a freelance reporter in New York, ten to one the story was an inside tip off or written as a favour to push a grudge. The equivalent of a journalist ringing up Private Eye in the UK to dish out some gossip on the guy who just scooped him / spilled his pint / nicked his bird.

The semi-professional bloggers who reported on this were doing nothing more than playing pundit, rehashing, reworking and commentating on the story, but not actually adding anything to it.

I've already written about how the blogosphere (blogobubble?) overhyped it's own relevance to the war in Iraq and without wanting to sound like a luddite I think a few deep breaths might be necessary before we kill traditional media. (what, again - that's soooo 1999).

More on this later.

Amsterdam, part one

This is getting blogged in chunks, it's late and I'm busy. However I should take the time to tell you all about Boom Chicago, cause otherwise you might go to Amsterdam and not go to see them - which would be a shame. If anyone reading this has seen 'Who's line is it anyway' it was a bit like that - a group of comediens improvising around things suggested by the audience. Unlike Who's Line there was a theme running through the whole show, the full title of which was 'Boom Chicago Saves The World (sorry about the mess), and half the scenes were scripted rather than pure improvisations.

Most of the show revolved around things Boom Chicago needed to save the world from. George Dubya and Tony featured heavily, but some of the best stuff was less political. Boom Chicago saves the world from American/Pop/whatever Idol was fantastic as was the mobile phone sketch. I'd go on, but it'll only be different if you go, whichI suggest you do.

Doh!

Tony has just done this. Which makes me feel bad for not having thought of it myself. Fear not, I shall ensure that one is called ito existance for next terms MBA class. Probably tomorrow.

Back from Amsterdam

Just back from Amsterdam and a weekend of barbeque, beer and improvised comedy. More later today.

Friday, June 06, 2003

Trigger happy policing

Business school is definately a good place for getting first hand experience of places. I just finished having lunch with a colleague who served with the British Army in Bosnia and told me about the differences between US and UK peacekeepers. The Americans it seemed continuted to wear helmets, flak jackets and weapons at the ready long after the rest of the troops had switched to berets, shirt sleeves and slung weapons. She thought this probably had something to do with the problems the US was having in Iraq.

I was still thinking about this when I came across this article about John Simpson, a man who has probably spent more time on battlefields than pretty much any serving soldier in the UK or US army. Sadly some of the news coming out of Basra suggests that UK troops haven't been on their best behaviour with regard to prisoners either - but it might be that there's a considerable difference between a culture of shoot first ask later, and a culture that tries not to.

Thursday, June 05, 2003

More on case studies

But not from me. Adam is at Harvard where case studies are the order of the day for teaching. He's written a piece on why he likes them, what they're like and what you get out of them. He also makes the very cogent point that this is all about personal preference, different schools teach in different ways.

Just to clear up my earlier posts, we do a fair amount of case work here, but it's not delivered in the same style. It's not the focus of most lectures and it's not generally something that requires a lot of preparation before hand. Exceptions were management accounting - taught by a visiting LBS professor (I dozed through the cases and learned in the lectures) and marketing, which was all about 21 submitted cases. These however were not normal cases, mostly custom written by the professor they were terrifying single side (sometimes more) explanations of what looked like (had to be, surely) simple problems.

We lived in fear of them

I've been Wallied!

For the best part of this term I've been working as a freelance copywriter for the school. The mission? To develop the 2004-5 MBA brochure. Well, after weeks of work crammed in around lectures, coursework and blogging the brochure is nearing completion. One critical test for me was the fact that Wally Olins was going to be checking the copy as a favour to the school. I found out what he thought of it yesterday.

It survived. No ringing praises, but a decided absence of red ink. Much, much better than I expected.

So, if anyone needs some copy writing my rates are as reasonable as my debts are high. As Blackadder once said "how fortunate that your job is also your hobby"

Wednesday, June 04, 2003

Three years of Hell to become the Devil

A former colleague and good friend has headed to law school. He's blogging the experience at his brand new weblog, tentatively titled "Three years of Hell to become the Devil". For those who find my politics absurd you'll love Tony's. If you agree with mine, you'll probably find he drives you to apoplexy. He's a great guy, mixes a mean drink and plays poker far too well for my taste.

If you're going to be a law student at Columbia next year this man will be your classmate, go say hi.

Taking blogs to Capitol Hill

Having brought weblogs to Parliament Tim has set his sights on Washington, if you're a US citizen you can help him.

Tuesday, June 03, 2003

Interesting stuff on oil

I've just read this rather long blog entry on oil production, the gist of which is that production is expected to peak in 2008 and then fall steadily. That sounds like scaremongering, but the evidence and argument make interesting reading. (I'm less inclined to believe the politics at the end...) Still I checked a few other figures from the paper

Here are the US oil production figures showing a peak in 1970, exactly when it was supposed to be (production is now below 1954 levels)

Here are the latest figures for OPEC (xls file) which show production as being more or less steady over recent years.

The thrust of the post linked above is not that we're about to run out of oil, just that once global production peaks and future reserves become more expensive to exploit the price of oil will rise and the economics of the market will be fundamentally changed. The fox in the henhouse here is the news last year that the Caspian Oil Fields were a fraction of the size they were expected to be, bringing forward estimated of peak production by some dozen years or so.

Now as with so many things I write about I don't have the information available to make a complete decision on this, but there seems to be a hypothesis worthy of some kind of follow up here.

Son of brand strategy

Second half of our brand strategy lecture today was given by our lecturer's son, who is one of the folks behind a brand planning agency in London. So far so good, indeed the prospect of 90 minutes on brand innovation was quite appealing, and the opening comments that 'there's a lot of stuff in this talk' and 'I'm not going to dumb it down cause you're oxford students' gave cause for optimism. Brand strategy has been by and large a bloody sophisticated class, lots of very good ideas in there.

Shame then that we got a 90 minute sales pitch, stuffed with almost no ideas whatsoever, a signal lack of evidence or case studies and a convincing proof that in the brand space mutton dressed as lamb sells as well now as it ever has.

Monday, June 02, 2003

HTML Typography

Back in the day I was good at HTML, I could do crazy things with table tags, I knew all about blockquotes, nbsp; spacers, single pixel gif tricks and browser bugs from netscapes 2 through 5 along with their corresponding IE flaws. Mac and PC, that's how good I was, serious webmonkey stuff.

But kids today have got shiny new toys that I just don't understand. Man, I've got to get me some skills and do stuff a little more like this...

On Politics and coursework


From a study group member

"kudos to:
martin, for writing some of the most high minded drivel i’ve read so far on this course"

You can rely on me for high minded drivel ;-)

Funny thing, I'm sure there aren't many people who take an MBA and as a result rediscover their preference for left wing economics, state paternalism and all the other political bits and pieces that get me worked up. Not to say that I've veered entirely to the left, in some respects I'm splitting down the middle. Parts of me now hold fairly ruthless views about competition, failing companies and the merits of inflexible work forces. On the other hand, now I've taken a good hard look at neo classical 'chicago' economics I can cheerfully say that I want none of it. And you can take your maximising shareholder value mantra with you as well, none of that for me please. Free trade? It's a mixed bag isn't it... Desirable in the long run, in need of careful and slow introduction in the short run.

I like Oxford, you can come here, challenge the ideas and even find that plenty of people have already challenged them on your behalf. Of course the quid pro quo for this is that they challenge you right back. While the faculty have opinions there's definately not a hint of dogma about the place. Well, maybe in some strategy classes, but they were co-taught by people who didn't agree with each other, so that was OK.

Sunday, June 01, 2003

On blogs and the war

I was going to write a longer piece about this, maybe a whole article, something I could send to a paper of note to get attention and make my point to a bigger public. That was a while ago, and since I haven't managed to write any long articles I guess you're going to have to make do with this blog entry about blogs, the war and the persistence of old media.

The war sparked an interest in blogs that largely missed the point. The internet, and blogs in particular were going to make this war different. We'd short circuit the corporate lies and get the inside scoop. People on the ground would offer up information and civilian experts would provide incisive commentary. CNN, Fox, the BBC, Al-Jazeera, all would be outmoded. Bush's war would be our revolution. Like so much else in the overhyped world of blogs this was garbage.

The internet did throw up a few interesting things during the war, almost all served to reinforce the position of old media and supported the propaganda of the various sides. The command-post was probably the biggest blog to look at the war, and rapidly evolved into something that was less blog, more news syndication and bulletin board service. Post war it has become a place to discuss all matters relating to the US military's operations. The command post did not however offer much in the way of original content, just links to stories from the newswires (overwhelmingly US) and patriotic commentary. Mainstream media was repackaged as alternative and the right wing digerati swallowed it whole.

Not that the left wing digerati were much better. Diametrically opposed to the command post was Iraqwar.ru and with one notable exception this site simply took in news from around the world, translated it into English and or Russian and republished it. While the presence of Arab sources was interesting they weren't saying much that wasn't appearing in UK broadsheets like the Times and the Guardian (both appeared regularly on the site). Iraqwar.ru wasn't a blog anymore than the command post was, and it carried equally little fresh information. The bulletin boards and opinion pieces were shot through with anti-american rhetoric, useful if you want to judge the mood in Cairo - but hardly a media revolution.

Iraqwar.ru did have one ace up it's sleeve though. Their daily briefings which appeared throughout the war were allegedly filed by former GRU agents now intent on exploiting old contacts to 'break the west's information blockade'. I've no idea if what they said was true, it fitted most of the facts western media reported and cast a very different complexion on the war as a whole. In the absence of some means of verifying their identity this groups' reporting had to be taken with a pinch of salt. The Guardian reported that clued in city traders were using it to pre-empt news releases from the west, but as I understand it city traders would place trades on the colour of the tie worn by CNN's anchormen if someone told them there was a pattern in it.

All of which brings me to the real blogs, the ones written by people who were actually there. There weren't many.

Lt Smash wrote a blog from a US military camp in (I think) the Saudi Arabian desert. He almost certainly knew an awful lot about what was going on. There was no way on earth he was going to share that information. He writes a good and entertaining blog about what it's like to be a US soldier, under pressure, 7000 miles from home. He gives great insight into the mind of the US soldier and what it is that motivates these guys and keeps them going. He was not however about to revolutionise media coverage of the war.

Kevin Sites is a journalist employed by CNN. He blogged plenty of stuff during the build up to the war, but once things started his corporate masters decided that blogging was not compatible with employment by CNN. Kevin stopped being an independent reporter on the side and focused full time on his day job. I think CNN missed a trick on this one, but I'm sure the situation was much more complex than I can imagine for the people taking the decisions.

Which finally brings me to Salaam Pax, author of the Dear Raed blog. It was his post of today, in response to some redneck idiots that got me to finally write this. Of all the thousands (myself included) who spilled digital ink during the conflict he's the only one I've found who could genuinely say what he felt and tell what he knew about everything. The destruction of the Baghdad phone system cut him off as the war got underway but he kept writing and published as soon as he could. For all that though Salaam is, as he says, just one guy, with one voice and one viewpoint. He doesn't have access to the big picture any more than we do. If we had a hundred folks like Salaam, soldiers, civilians, aid workers, civil servants and reporters of both sides we might just have been able to synthesise it into a coherent picture, but we don't.

Blogging, the internet and communal journalism was overhyped. Worse by building the illusion that there was a mass of independent, sceptical experts ready to pounce on the misdemeanours of big media we simply legitimised them whenever we recycled their stories. Just like last time, what you made of the war came down to who's papers you liked to read. The second Iraq war was a triumph for old media, and we shouldn't forget that.

Soul of a new Machine

If you haven't read this book I'd suggest you correct that right now. I'd also suggest that you don't follow this link to a follow up piece in wired that appeared some twenty years after the events described in the book, it'll spoil all the fun.

I first read the book a long time ago, I guess I was 14, maybe a little older. I had no idea about business at the time, no clue at all as to what went on inside companies, but I liked the book, the story of the struggle, the fact that it was real, the careful descriptions of the in-jokes, rituals and shared culture that drives the IT industry. I'm not sure other industries are like that. Perhaps it's because there are so many IT companies, because the work is so complex and arcane, because it attracts a certain kind of mindset. I'm not sure.

I think I'd feel like a tourist in a real IT company, I guess I can find out when I spend the summer at Cisco. Meanwhile the internet age is still waiting for a pulitzer prize winning novel...

Friday, May 30, 2003

How to buy IT

Its a pretty fair bet that The Register's new content management solution will work, that their site will not suffer unfeasible amounts of downtime during the rebuild and that they've save a fortune by going to an Open Source product. One day big corporations will realise that shelling out hundreds of thousands for the traditional enterprise toolkits is not the way to do this. Find something that works, hire some people who can use it and get on with it.

Web technology is not difficult and for the most part doesn't come close to having high complexity tasks involved. It can and should be done on the cheap whenever possible. I await the Registers case study with interest.

The Matrix Reloaded (some spoilers included)

Since everyone is reviewing this here are my thoughts on what's certainly the most talked about film at the moment. It wasn't that good. Out went ground breaking special effects, in came effects we've all seen before. Out went Keanu Reeves looking confused for a whole film and a plot laced with dubious philosophy and in came... no wait, that stuff was still there.

Somehow this movie just didn't cut it for me. First time round the Matrix involved a poor plot but fantastic special effects, action sequences and a uber-cool look we hadn't seen before. This was just more of the same, and fundamentally there was nothing in the film to make you care about it. Neo is attacked by swarms of agents - we don't care as we know he can handle them, Zion is under threat - who cares, we hardly get to see it and it's not a very sympathetic place. The machines are divided between themselves, who cares, it's hard to see how any of this affects our heroes. Bombs explode, bullets whizz by, Kung Fu is performed and at the end of the day my heartrate barely changed.

They could have done so much better. The ultimate denoument where the workings of the Matrix and meaning of the One are explained was good, but the stuff leading up to it was weak, pseudo intellectualism masquerading as deep philosophy. The society of the machines has fantastic potential for developing characters and groups, but aside from the hugely enjoyable Twins all we get are by the numbers Hollywood henchmen.

In the end the Wachowski brothers have accomplished little more than anyone else with a similar budget and background in directing could have done. There are no claims to genius here, the fight choreography doesn't really open up as well as John Woo's stuff, the panorama's don't compare to the stuff Ridley Scott comes out with and the action sequences were stock Hollywood stuff plus last years special effects. If I was them I'd have worked overtime for a new effect to compare with bullet time, it was the innovation we loved, the newness of it, not the fact that time stood still as things moved around. Nothing new here I'm afraid.

Don't even get me started on the superman sequences and the bloody Merovingian...

Thursday, May 29, 2003

Free speech?

Over on the other side of the pond Doc is all up in arms about plans to deregulate the media. The (increasingly political) Register have an even more extreme point of view.

Wednesday, May 28, 2003

Class war part 32456983

The news that the number of state school pupils coming to Oxford is down this year is sure to hit the headlines again. I've got a few comments on this...

With students already being forced to pay more for their education and carry more debt, wouldn't you expect a migration away from one of the most expensive cities in the UK? Starting with those least able to pay? You can trade in three years of Oxford and brideshead revisited for three years of Manchester, Liverpool, Newcastle or Birmingham - party towns with respected universities, and rents that are between 40 and 60% of the Oxford ones.

There is still no evidence that the Oxford selection process for undergraduates is biased in any way about anything. It turns out that if 40% of acceptances are from state schools its because so were 40% of applications, the same goes for women, ethnic minorities, disabled, left wing, right wing... you get the idea. The problem is all in the image.

When the chancellor of the exchequer picks a fight with the university on the grounds that its elitist what people remember is just that. Never mind that he was wrong about that and pretty much everything else he said at the time.

Straight outta the Matrix

Since Tad and Lucky had both taken this quiz I thought I'd give it a go and what do I get?

Neo

So was it told about the long dark coat, shaved head and sunglasses, or did it just know? And all that time I wanted to be Morpheus.

Tuesday, May 27, 2003

Case teaching

Case teaching at Oxford is a bit of an odd affair. Actually working through a case, start to finish is a bit of an oddity. More often they become topics for discussion, pulled in to illustrate points or show theory being put into practice. It's certainly only the guest lecturers who turn them into the centrepiece of any given lecture.

Today we had a visiting lecturer from LBS, formerly at Wharton and possibly Harvard (I forget) who took us through the Snapple case, on which he is apparently some kind of expert. Now, give the man his due it was entertaining stuff. He was lively, animated, and opinionated. He wrote things on the board and ploughed relentlessly through his notes, he had a gameplan for the next hour and he was not to be deflected. Questions rained down on the class, we quickly realised that all the answers were written on the pages of the case, look at the page, read something off and hey presto, you're in the good books. Hardly any need to think at all.

Post case though and I'm sitting here wondering what I learned. One hour of case study later here is what was taught

1. Market research is a useful starting point when branding a product
2. Most brands get started by accident
3. Its not about brands, its always about a Brand

To take these one at a time I've rarely seen a company that couldn't produce market research to explain it's latest dumb idea, and there was no discussion of what makes research good, bad or indifferent, of the kind of questions you should ask or the manner in which you should interpret the results. Just a maxim, research is good. In fact research often just tells you that what consumers want today they'll want again tomorrow. Not exactly groundbreaking stuff.

While many entrepreneurs do indeed end up with a brand largely by accident. (a powerbrand in this case) plenty of people plan brands very deliberately. Dr Peppers' Raging Cow, Hutchinson Whampoas' 3 and Mercedes / Swatches' Smart Car all spring to mind as recent examples.

The last point is just a nice bit of rhetoric. The case study method, good way to pass the time or intellectually stimulating? Discuss.

Monday, May 26, 2003

Ethical oil?

I'm currently drafting the first couple of sections for my groups project on corporate responsibility. We're supposed to prepare a corporate responsibility plan, a set of implementation recommendations and a description of likely opposition to our ideas and way for overcoming this. My group has chosen to prepare a piece on an oil company, currently going by the name of Exoff.

This is a fairly tricky thing to do. Framing general principles in a manner that means they can't be twisted out of all recognition, but still retain some tangible meaning is hard going. Slightly harder going though is doing this for real. One member of the group worked with a major oil company in China and outlined a series of dilemmas for us that made it easy to see just how easy it is for companies to give into the temptation to do something wrong and why western companies may well feel like their ethical ideals hold them back in developing (and under-regulated markets).

Could be worse though. You could be the British Home Secretary, trying to fight back the overwhelming temptation to introduce ID cards and pander to the knee jerk xenophobia of the 'Great' British Public.

About time too

Looks like US lawmakers are planning to crack down on spam. While this is a good thing in itself I imagine it won't be long before spammers relocate to less well governed nations. Of course if top level ISP's would get their act together and crack down on this we could probably cut the spam problem in half in a matter of months, but as long as there's money in bandwidth...

Sunday, May 25, 2003

The Mathematical Bridge

There are many interesting things about travelling with a class full of MBA's. One was the reason our Chinese students got so interested in the Mathematical Bridge in Cambridge. It's claimed this bridge was designed by Newton in a manner that required no bolts, nails, screws or anything else. Later the bridge was taken apart to find out how it worked, but subsequently could not be reassembled and today is held together by bolts. This however was not why the Chinese students were interested.

It turns out that in 1928 one of China's most famous poets, Xu Zhimo, wrote a poem about his time in Cambridge, and it's considered a masterpiece in China. I'm also told this translation doesn't do it justice. Seems nice enough to me...

The Mathematical Bridge

Very quietly I take my leave
As quietly as I came here;
Quietly I wave good-bye
To the rosy clouds in the western sky.

The golden willows by the riverside
Are young brides in the setting sun;
Their reflections on the shimmering waves
Always linger in the depth of my heart.

The floating heart growing in the sludge
Sways leisurely under the water;
In the gentle waves of Cambridge
I would be a water plant!

That pool under the shade of elm trees
Holds not water but the rainbow from the sky;
Shattered to pieces among the duck weeds
Is the sediment of a rainbow-like dream?

To seek a dream?
Just to pole a boat upstream
To where the green grass is more verdant;
Or to have the boat fully loaded with starlight
And sing aloud in the splendour of starlight.

But I cannot sing aloud
Quietness is my farewell music;
Even summer insects keep silence for me
Silent is Cambridge tonight!

Very quietly I take my leave
As quietly as I came here;
Gently I flick my sleeves
Not even a wisp of cloud will I bring away

Blogs at Harvard

So Harvard take on Dave Winer to sort out their thinking about IT and Law or something and lo and behold this happens

Its looking increasingly as if I'll be around in Oxford over the summer and I'd like to lean on a few people to try and get things like this happening. I'd also like to start a project to produce a new kind of case study. One from which you could learn a little more, and which might bear more resemblence to the real world. Which reminds me, on Tuesday we've got a guest lecturer from LBS coming in who apparantly is an expert in both the 'harvard case study method' and 'the snapple case'. Yes, that's right, this man is known for his ability to take a class through a single case study, thirty or so sides of A4 devoted to the manufacture, marketing and distribution of a range of soft drinks. I know Adam Smith said it was good, but isn't this level of specialisation getting a bit much?



Saturday, May 24, 2003

Live from Cambridge!

Just a quick note, I'm here at the Judge Institute for Cambridge hanging out after the last football game of the season. Today both sides have given their all in football, tennis, basketball, and cricket. Sad to report Oxford have brought home only the basketball trophy, but we challenged well on alll fronts.

Full report to follow. Right now there is wine to drink and people to talk to ;-)

Friday, May 23, 2003

Arghhh

This is going to really really really spoil football for me. I suppose he could still fail the medical but... Oh, and Freddy Shepherd is the highest paid chairman in football. I swear something is very rotten in the state of newcastle united.

Update

Lots to talk about, but not much time to talk with I'm afraid. Lets see

I've landed a summer business project with a major technology company. I can't say too much about it because we're still negotiating the details of how we're going to work with them and there's a chance it could fall through. More on this as it emerges.

In other news my preparations for the football match against Cambridge business school (Judge) have been thrown into disarray by my managing to badly bruise my right foot, which makes playing football kind of difficult. So I'm facing a fitness test tomorrow and I'm rating myself less than 50/50 for the big match. Still there's a whole festival of sports planned for the day at cambridge so I may manage to play cricket or basketball - anything that doesn't involve kicking things with my feet is still an option.

I really have to get started on the coursework for this term. I'm planning on starting on the ethics case this afternoon, I've got two individual and two group assignments for branding - and I plan to knock out the individual ones soon.

Finally rumours have reached me of an interesting job in warwick. It's hardly ideal locationwise, but the job is interesting and it's near an airport, which is important when your better half will be living in Holland. This is good news, because all the work is seriously impeding my ability to jobhunt.

Wednesday, May 21, 2003

Life after wartime

Salaam Pax has been out on the road with Raed, touring the south of Iraq and compiling lists of civilian casualties. That's grim enough, but its the emerging fanaticsm he records that scares me. Looters in Basra destroyed off licenses and attacked the owners. Clerics are preaching that those who sell alcohol or show films of 'loose women' (according to Salaam that would include Britney Spears videos) will be given a week to desist or face the consequences.

If the Americans want to avoid radical islamists taking over parts of the country (if not the whole country) they're going to have to stay longer than they expected I think. You can read his report with accompanying photographs at electronic iraq

Term gets serious

The stress is getting to us. Our usual diet of debate, serious discussions of economic policy, views on the efficiency of the market and critiques of the Black Scholes model have been replaced with a viscious email argument as to whether or not Noo Noo the hoover can be considered an honorary tellytubby.

I'm telling you, there's only four of the buggers. Tinky Winky, La La, Dipsy and Po. Don't believe me, look at this from their website.

Tuesday, May 20, 2003

No No No NO NO NO NO NO

This is terrible news. The signing of Woodgate was bad enough. Adding Bowyer, a man who's past is not so much dodgy as an integral part of footballs heart of darkness is horrible. Never mind that he's been a disaster at West Ham as well. Agressive, unpleasant and probably racist. I don't want Newcastle to become like Leeds were in their 'glory days', a team full of spite and visciousness masquerading as professionalism and fighting spirit.

Lets hope it falls through.

Words of sanity on this from Biffa and Nial.

Saturday, May 17, 2003

Joseph Stiglitz, live at the examination schools, part II

OK, all pretence of this being live will have to be abandoned. Not only am I writing about this a day later, I'm writing this having been to part III. Still here is part II, foundations of a new economics. No ambition here then...

The lecture started by covering a number of market imperfections and their consequences. Most of these related to credit and equity rationing. The point of credit is that it lets you draw down future consumption for present use, however as any undergraduate student will testify trying to draw down future (uncertain) income is really rather hard. Since banks often don't know who is credit worthy a market imperfection ensues. While you can argue this causes the price of debt to rise and is otherwise insignificant in fact it makes it hard for investment to be channeled into poorly performing economies, especially when balance sheet effects (see below) are taken into account.

Current Chicago macroeconomic theory assumes that neither credit nor equity rationing will apply if a firm can demonstrate that it is a good investment. In fact the empirical evidence suggests there's plenty of it.

Other imperfections stem from cash flow and balance sheet effects. In particular, when a country devalues its currency debts owed and owing change dramatically. Firms who owe in foreign currency find themselves hugely in debt and unable to invest. This often affects domestic banks and credit rationing ensues.

New monetary ideas
Most transactions now take place on credit, so the cost of holding money and demand for money in the usual sense are actually extremely low. What's important is the supply of credit in the economy which depends heavily on how well informed banks are and how strong their balance sheets are.

It seems my notes aren't as good as I thought, so some of this may be a little garbled. The conclusion however I've written down as follows

"Taken together these theories suggest that markets are not self sdjusting. Fiscal policy can be expansionary"

Friday, May 16, 2003

Work in progress

I'm a bit snowed at the moment, stuff I'll be posting in the next day or so includes the write up of the last two Stiglitz lectures. Joseph took it upon himself to expound what he hopes will be a new economic orthodoxy, so I need to make sure my writeup makes sense or I'll misrepresent him.

There was also a panel discussion on Biotech last night, which was useful because my project for Managing Technology Ventures is about biotech companies. So I've collected the business cards and am now hunting down interview subjects. It also taught me a hell of a lot about an industry of which I knew little. I've been to a couple of these panel discussions, which are primarily about careers, but I wish I'd been to more. Not because I want to work in each and every industry that's appeared, but because its very useful to get an insight into what these different sectors are up to.

Thursday, May 15, 2003

More reasons to move to Scotland

Tom Watson, the blogging MP is mad about the introduction of PR in Scotland for local elections. (thats Proportional Representation). I'm on the fence about PR, but now it seems that we're going to get a trial of it in Scotland.

The list of things coming out of the deal reads like a list of good reasons to move to Scotland. Add the better legal system, licensing laws and pensions to that lot and it's clear that devolution is paying off in a country where socialism is not only acceptable, but accepted and practiced.

Three cool things

Cool thing one is the Starwars kid. Cool thing two is the Starwars kid remix. The coolest thing of all though is the bit torrent client you'll need to download to get the videos from this site. One of the niftiest concepts I've seen in ages. Peer to peer just keeps on getting better...

Swarming downloads. Just sounds sooo cool and science fiction doesn't it?

Face to face with Shell

Give them credit, Shell sent along two senior executives (well, one senior and one former senior) to our discussion on Shell's involvement in Nigeria, part of our Corporate Responsibility session. I've been tough on Shell in the past in this blog (murderous organisation, or words to that effect) so I was interested to see what came out. I nearly didn't make it though, since half the lecture clashed with Joseph Stiglitz at the exam schools. Fortunately it was the half about other stuff.

After a discussion of the case it was into a direct Q&A of the shell staff. One was a senior figure from the UK branch, the other a former senior manager from Nigeria. The big questions focused on two things. How can Shell defend its environmental record in the area, and how can they have justified their actions around the trial and execution of Ken Saro Wiwa. On both counts Shell seem to be genuinely contrite. The environmental record seems to be improving and their definition of what counts as political participation is much broader now than it was then. They probably are a much nicer organisation now than they were twenty or even five years ago.

On the case of Ken Saro Wiwa I asked how each of them felt personally when they heard about the death. The guy from the UK talked about the shock Shell employees felt at the following public revulsion. John Major called it judicial murder, people's kids were attacked in school on account of their parent's jobs, dinner party conversation probably got nasty. It seems to have been a genuine wake up call to the company at all levels.

More interesting was the guy from Nigeria. He felt, he said "shocked". Neither he nor anyone else believed that Abacha would carry out the executions without an appeal, or that having got a guilty verdict he'd commute the death sentence. I think the executions genuinely caught the company by surprise, they thought if they kept their mouths shut it would all blow over. Saro Wiwa would be jailed and the corporation forgotten about again.

Shell aren't going to ever be able to fully repair the environmental damage they did. Nigerias political problems go way beyond the activities of one man. I do think though that Shell is now a better company than it was then, primarily as the result of public pressure, outrage and the efforts of thousands of activists impacting on the thousands of individual decision makers within Shell.

As Chris Locke points out in Gonzo Marketing, to suggest that companies have principles or morals in erroneous. No company ever felt anything, no company ever fell in love. It's people that do all that stuff. Behind even the most faceless modern corporation lurk real people, and making a difference is about reaching them.

Wednesday, May 14, 2003

Something in these blogs

I've just heard about a candidate turning down a business school because of something they read in a blog, and before anyone gets all het up it wasn't this school they turned down and it wasn't because of my blog. Of course they felt the need to explain themselves to the blogger in question and did so in a way that made clear just how unpleasant some people can be.

So just in case the person in question is reading this stuff and recognises themselves, go apologise. There's rarely a good excuse for being unpleasant to strangers.

On the plus side this is what MBA blogging is about, you give a flavour of the institution and people get to decide if they want to go.

Tuesday, May 13, 2003

Joseph Stiglitz, live from the examination schools (Part I)

OK, it's not live, they don't have network points at the examination schools. But here is what Stiglitz, nobel prize winning economist, former head of the World Bank and outspoken critic of the IMF had to say.

First Keynesianism has been unfairly overlooked in recent times, in favour of an economic orthodoxy based around the free market economics of the Chicago School. This is predicated on a number of ideas which he believes to be innacurate. These are the conceptions of business cycles, the efficiency of the free market and the undesirability of government intervention. I'll try and take each of these in turn, but I'm being brief here, so I guess you should read his books if you want to know more.

Business Cycles
No such thing says Stiglitz. Its important to realise that this isn't denying booms busts or recessions, just the idea that one is necessarily followed by the other. While neo-classical economists like to explain these as caused by the market adjusting itself toward an equilibrium Stiglitz sees them as caused by external shocks such as investment bubbles (internet stocks) or fiscal crises (Asian banking runs). When these things happen the market does not necessarily respond efficiently, often it exacerbates and locks in the problem, at which point some kind of external factor is needed to get things back on track.

Free market efficiency
The argument about the inefficiency of the free market chiefly comes down to information asymetries. Some of these are obvious - the accounting scandals make clear that markets often act on false information. Other evidence comes from the failure of even large corporations to fully exploit the tax system - if the market was efficient they wouldn't be leaving this money on the table. A slightly more complex point is that for most activities we don't know what an efficient use of resources is - how much effort should it take GM to make a car? GM might say they're at the efficient level now, comparison with Japanese factories suggests they're at 50%, and the Japanese think there's plenty of room for improvement.

The (un)desirablility of government intervention
While governments may well do stupid and damaging things from time to time this is largely because they're misguided (and he was quite ready to blame the IMF for providing the poor guidance). However they can intervene for good and because of points one and two above they should do so. This is in direct opposition to the view of the Chicago school which holds that government intervention is what causes market inefficiency in the first place.

There was plenty more of this, with a look at the disconnect in neo classical economics between micro and macro economic evidence, a discussion of price rigidity / flexibility and a look at what deflation does to economies. But there will be more on that tomorrow I'm told, so I guess I'll leave you waiting for it.

Yesterdays papers

Well, this site is now officially old news, but that doesn't seem to have deterred the traffic influx. While a fair chunk of this is due to the blog links I asked for and got yesterday there's been a big upsurge in people coming in from search engines. I guess this could be down to the newspaper coverage - don't recall seeing many people searching for my name before...

Dear Raed is back

Salaam Pax, who runs 'Dear Raed', the blog from Baghdad is back online. The good news is he seems to have come through the war OK and even though he didn't have web access he continued to write posts for release after the war.

You can buy a handgrenade in Baghdad for 25c, armed gangs fight over license plates and abandoned munitions, Fedayeen still snipe at Americans who retaliate by shelling residential areas (including Salaam's), dozens of political parties argue the toss and no one seems to have a good word to say about the USA.

Read about it all here

Monday, May 12, 2003

Coming attractions

While the weblogs versus the newspapers experiment plays itself out below I may as well mention some coming attractions on this blog. On Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel Prize Winning Economist is lecturing at the Exam Schools on whether or not Keynes is Dead. I like Keynes, so I hope the answer is no. I'll be posting my thoughts on his lectures up here, assuming I can get in, I can see him being popular.

Funny thing. Until about a month ago I'd never heard of Stiglitz. Then I saw the lecture title and thought 'cool, I should go'. Then Zaeem read one of my rants about Milton Friedman and suggested Stiglitz as the antidote. Then my sister suggested I buy her a copy of his latest book for her birthday. (she's a much better read left winger than me...)

In other news, Labour may be divided, but when was the last time a tory resigned on principle?