It's sad
Luck Goldstar thinks I've been on a tear lately. He doesn't know the half of it. Today was depressing. We had our first class on corporate responsibility. We watched a panorama report on Nike and Gap's use of third world (Cambodian) labour in 2000. Then we discussed it. Never mind that 12 year olds had been pressed into work by family and social pressure, never mind that workers were on 16 hour shifts without a break for slave wages. Never mind that these poor people are living in a shanty town.
To see some of my colleagues find the justifications, to parrot out the corporate line. It turned my stomach. I'm convinced that not one of the people in that room would have run the factory in the video the way it was run. If instead of sloping off to our pretty jobs in corporateville we took a job running a factory in Cambodia we wouldn't be like this. We wouldn't allow staff to beat the workers for asking for time off. We wouldn't enforce overtime or insist on sixteen hour shifts. We'd find a way to pay more than the minimum wage. We wouldn't hire 12 year olds who look like 12 year olds. We'd be better than that. But ask us in the abstract, ask us if it might be ok, ask us about the unreal world of rhetoric...
You see its not real, its in Cambodia, which if any of us have been there at all is a place you go on holiday. Pass through travelling and look at the temples. Smoke something interesting and don't tread on the landmines. Nike and Gap outsourced their morals and exported ours. Can we have absoloute morals, yeah, don't hit your workforce. Can we tell the age of a worker, yeah, don't employ kids with puppy fat. Can we do anything about the Nike shoes and Gap clothes in our wardrobe? Yeah, justify the company in class. Salve your conscience.
My football boots are Nike (see above). My music is from paid up members of the RIAA (assaults on privacy and civil liberty), my laptop is Dell (God knows what's inside). We've gotta get out of this place, but they sold the exit signs while we weren't looking.
Meanwhile, if like Lucky you're forming your opinions of No Logo from the pages of the Economist take a moment to
read this. Personally I'd suggest you read the book. Naomi is by no means perfect, plenty of her evidence is open to challenge and badly handled, but don't buy second hand opinions kids, you don't know where they've been.