A year long blog describing what its like to take an MBA at a top business school. From application to graduation..
Monday, June 09, 2003
Friday, June 06, 2003
Trigger happy policing
Business school is definately a good place for getting first hand experience of places. I just finished having lunch with a colleague who served with the British Army in Bosnia and told me about the differences between US and UK peacekeepers. The Americans it seemed continuted to wear helmets, flak jackets and weapons at the ready long after the rest of the troops had switched to berets, shirt sleeves and slung weapons. She thought this probably had something to do with the problems the US was having in Iraq.I was still thinking about this when I came across this article about John Simpson, a man who has probably spent more time on battlefields than pretty much any serving soldier in the UK or US army. Sadly some of the news coming out of Basra suggests that UK troops haven't been on their best behaviour with regard to prisoners either - but it might be that there's a considerable difference between a culture of shoot first ask later, and a culture that tries not to.
Thursday, June 05, 2003
More on case studies
But not from me. Adam is at Harvard where case studies are the order of the day for teaching. He's written a piece on why he likes them, what they're like and what you get out of them. He also makes the very cogent point that this is all about personal preference, different schools teach in different ways.Just to clear up my earlier posts, we do a fair amount of case work here, but it's not delivered in the same style. It's not the focus of most lectures and it's not generally something that requires a lot of preparation before hand. Exceptions were management accounting - taught by a visiting LBS professor (I dozed through the cases and learned in the lectures) and marketing, which was all about 21 submitted cases. These however were not normal cases, mostly custom written by the professor they were terrifying single side (sometimes more) explanations of what looked like (had to be, surely) simple problems.
We lived in fear of them
I've been Wallied!
For the best part of this term I've been working as a freelance copywriter for the school. The mission? To develop the 2004-5 MBA brochure. Well, after weeks of work crammed in around lectures, coursework and blogging the brochure is nearing completion. One critical test for me was the fact that Wally Olins was going to be checking the copy as a favour to the school. I found out what he thought of it yesterday.It survived. No ringing praises, but a decided absence of red ink. Much, much better than I expected.
So, if anyone needs some copy writing my rates are as reasonable as my debts are high. As Blackadder once said "how fortunate that your job is also your hobby"
Wednesday, June 04, 2003
Three years of Hell to become the Devil
A former colleague and good friend has headed to law school. He's blogging the experience at his brand new weblog, tentatively titled "Three years of Hell to become the Devil". For those who find my politics absurd you'll love Tony's. If you agree with mine, you'll probably find he drives you to apoplexy. He's a great guy, mixes a mean drink and plays poker far too well for my taste.If you're going to be a law student at Columbia next year this man will be your classmate, go say hi.
Taking blogs to Capitol Hill
Having brought weblogs to Parliament Tim has set his sights on Washington, if you're a US citizen you can help him.Tuesday, June 03, 2003
Interesting stuff on oil
I've just read this rather long blog entry on oil production, the gist of which is that production is expected to peak in 2008 and then fall steadily. That sounds like scaremongering, but the evidence and argument make interesting reading. (I'm less inclined to believe the politics at the end...) Still I checked a few other figures from the paperHere are the US oil production figures showing a peak in 1970, exactly when it was supposed to be (production is now below 1954 levels)
Here are the latest figures for OPEC (xls file) which show production as being more or less steady over recent years.
The thrust of the post linked above is not that we're about to run out of oil, just that once global production peaks and future reserves become more expensive to exploit the price of oil will rise and the economics of the market will be fundamentally changed. The fox in the henhouse here is the news last year that the Caspian Oil Fields were a fraction of the size they were expected to be, bringing forward estimated of peak production by some dozen years or so.
Now as with so many things I write about I don't have the information available to make a complete decision on this, but there seems to be a hypothesis worthy of some kind of follow up here.
Son of brand strategy
Second half of our brand strategy lecture today was given by our lecturer's son, who is one of the folks behind a brand planning agency in London. So far so good, indeed the prospect of 90 minutes on brand innovation was quite appealing, and the opening comments that 'there's a lot of stuff in this talk' and 'I'm not going to dumb it down cause you're oxford students' gave cause for optimism. Brand strategy has been by and large a bloody sophisticated class, lots of very good ideas in there.Shame then that we got a 90 minute sales pitch, stuffed with almost no ideas whatsoever, a signal lack of evidence or case studies and a convincing proof that in the brand space mutton dressed as lamb sells as well now as it ever has.
Monday, June 02, 2003
HTML Typography
Back in the day I was good at HTML, I could do crazy things with table tags, I knew all about blockquotes, nbsp; spacers, single pixel gif tricks and browser bugs from netscapes 2 through 5 along with their corresponding IE flaws. Mac and PC, that's how good I was, serious webmonkey stuff.But kids today have got shiny new toys that I just don't understand. Man, I've got to get me some skills and do stuff a little more like this...
On Politics and coursework
From a study group member
"kudos to:
martin, for writing some of the most high minded drivel i’ve read so far on this course"
You can rely on me for high minded drivel ;-)
Funny thing, I'm sure there aren't many people who take an MBA and as a result rediscover their preference for left wing economics, state paternalism and all the other political bits and pieces that get me worked up. Not to say that I've veered entirely to the left, in some respects I'm splitting down the middle. Parts of me now hold fairly ruthless views about competition, failing companies and the merits of inflexible work forces. On the other hand, now I've taken a good hard look at neo classical 'chicago' economics I can cheerfully say that I want none of it. And you can take your maximising shareholder value mantra with you as well, none of that for me please. Free trade? It's a mixed bag isn't it... Desirable in the long run, in need of careful and slow introduction in the short run.
I like Oxford, you can come here, challenge the ideas and even find that plenty of people have already challenged them on your behalf. Of course the quid pro quo for this is that they challenge you right back. While the faculty have opinions there's definately not a hint of dogma about the place. Well, maybe in some strategy classes, but they were co-taught by people who didn't agree with each other, so that was OK.
Sunday, June 01, 2003
On blogs and the war
I was going to write a longer piece about this, maybe a whole article, something I could send to a paper of note to get attention and make my point to a bigger public. That was a while ago, and since I haven't managed to write any long articles I guess you're going to have to make do with this blog entry about blogs, the war and the persistence of old media.The war sparked an interest in blogs that largely missed the point. The internet, and blogs in particular were going to make this war different. We'd short circuit the corporate lies and get the inside scoop. People on the ground would offer up information and civilian experts would provide incisive commentary. CNN, Fox, the BBC, Al-Jazeera, all would be outmoded. Bush's war would be our revolution. Like so much else in the overhyped world of blogs this was garbage.
The internet did throw up a few interesting things during the war, almost all served to reinforce the position of old media and supported the propaganda of the various sides. The command-post was probably the biggest blog to look at the war, and rapidly evolved into something that was less blog, more news syndication and bulletin board service. Post war it has become a place to discuss all matters relating to the US military's operations. The command post did not however offer much in the way of original content, just links to stories from the newswires (overwhelmingly US) and patriotic commentary. Mainstream media was repackaged as alternative and the right wing digerati swallowed it whole.
Not that the left wing digerati were much better. Diametrically opposed to the command post was Iraqwar.ru and with one notable exception this site simply took in news from around the world, translated it into English and or Russian and republished it. While the presence of Arab sources was interesting they weren't saying much that wasn't appearing in UK broadsheets like the Times and the Guardian (both appeared regularly on the site). Iraqwar.ru wasn't a blog anymore than the command post was, and it carried equally little fresh information. The bulletin boards and opinion pieces were shot through with anti-american rhetoric, useful if you want to judge the mood in Cairo - but hardly a media revolution.
Iraqwar.ru did have one ace up it's sleeve though. Their daily briefings which appeared throughout the war were allegedly filed by former GRU agents now intent on exploiting old contacts to 'break the west's information blockade'. I've no idea if what they said was true, it fitted most of the facts western media reported and cast a very different complexion on the war as a whole. In the absence of some means of verifying their identity this groups' reporting had to be taken with a pinch of salt. The Guardian reported that clued in city traders were using it to pre-empt news releases from the west, but as I understand it city traders would place trades on the colour of the tie worn by CNN's anchormen if someone told them there was a pattern in it.
All of which brings me to the real blogs, the ones written by people who were actually there. There weren't many.
Lt Smash wrote a blog from a US military camp in (I think) the Saudi Arabian desert. He almost certainly knew an awful lot about what was going on. There was no way on earth he was going to share that information. He writes a good and entertaining blog about what it's like to be a US soldier, under pressure, 7000 miles from home. He gives great insight into the mind of the US soldier and what it is that motivates these guys and keeps them going. He was not however about to revolutionise media coverage of the war.
Kevin Sites is a journalist employed by CNN. He blogged plenty of stuff during the build up to the war, but once things started his corporate masters decided that blogging was not compatible with employment by CNN. Kevin stopped being an independent reporter on the side and focused full time on his day job. I think CNN missed a trick on this one, but I'm sure the situation was much more complex than I can imagine for the people taking the decisions.
Which finally brings me to Salaam Pax, author of the Dear Raed blog. It was his post of today, in response to some redneck idiots that got me to finally write this. Of all the thousands (myself included) who spilled digital ink during the conflict he's the only one I've found who could genuinely say what he felt and tell what he knew about everything. The destruction of the Baghdad phone system cut him off as the war got underway but he kept writing and published as soon as he could. For all that though Salaam is, as he says, just one guy, with one voice and one viewpoint. He doesn't have access to the big picture any more than we do. If we had a hundred folks like Salaam, soldiers, civilians, aid workers, civil servants and reporters of both sides we might just have been able to synthesise it into a coherent picture, but we don't.
Blogging, the internet and communal journalism was overhyped. Worse by building the illusion that there was a mass of independent, sceptical experts ready to pounce on the misdemeanours of big media we simply legitimised them whenever we recycled their stories. Just like last time, what you made of the war came down to who's papers you liked to read. The second Iraq war was a triumph for old media, and we shouldn't forget that.
Soul of a new Machine
If you haven't read this book I'd suggest you correct that right now. I'd also suggest that you don't follow this link to a follow up piece in wired that appeared some twenty years after the events described in the book, it'll spoil all the fun.I first read the book a long time ago, I guess I was 14, maybe a little older. I had no idea about business at the time, no clue at all as to what went on inside companies, but I liked the book, the story of the struggle, the fact that it was real, the careful descriptions of the in-jokes, rituals and shared culture that drives the IT industry. I'm not sure other industries are like that. Perhaps it's because there are so many IT companies, because the work is so complex and arcane, because it attracts a certain kind of mindset. I'm not sure.
I think I'd feel like a tourist in a real IT company, I guess I can find out when I spend the summer at Cisco. Meanwhile the internet age is still waiting for a pulitzer prize winning novel...
Friday, May 30, 2003
How to buy IT
Its a pretty fair bet that The Register's new content management solution will work, that their site will not suffer unfeasible amounts of downtime during the rebuild and that they've save a fortune by going to an Open Source product. One day big corporations will realise that shelling out hundreds of thousands for the traditional enterprise toolkits is not the way to do this. Find something that works, hire some people who can use it and get on with it.Web technology is not difficult and for the most part doesn't come close to having high complexity tasks involved. It can and should be done on the cheap whenever possible. I await the Registers case study with interest.
The Matrix Reloaded (some spoilers included)
Since everyone is reviewing this here are my thoughts on what's certainly the most talked about film at the moment. It wasn't that good. Out went ground breaking special effects, in came effects we've all seen before. Out went Keanu Reeves looking confused for a whole film and a plot laced with dubious philosophy and in came... no wait, that stuff was still there.Somehow this movie just didn't cut it for me. First time round the Matrix involved a poor plot but fantastic special effects, action sequences and a uber-cool look we hadn't seen before. This was just more of the same, and fundamentally there was nothing in the film to make you care about it. Neo is attacked by swarms of agents - we don't care as we know he can handle them, Zion is under threat - who cares, we hardly get to see it and it's not a very sympathetic place. The machines are divided between themselves, who cares, it's hard to see how any of this affects our heroes. Bombs explode, bullets whizz by, Kung Fu is performed and at the end of the day my heartrate barely changed.
They could have done so much better. The ultimate denoument where the workings of the Matrix and meaning of the One are explained was good, but the stuff leading up to it was weak, pseudo intellectualism masquerading as deep philosophy. The society of the machines has fantastic potential for developing characters and groups, but aside from the hugely enjoyable Twins all we get are by the numbers Hollywood henchmen.
In the end the Wachowski brothers have accomplished little more than anyone else with a similar budget and background in directing could have done. There are no claims to genius here, the fight choreography doesn't really open up as well as John Woo's stuff, the panorama's don't compare to the stuff Ridley Scott comes out with and the action sequences were stock Hollywood stuff plus last years special effects. If I was them I'd have worked overtime for a new effect to compare with bullet time, it was the innovation we loved, the newness of it, not the fact that time stood still as things moved around. Nothing new here I'm afraid.
Don't even get me started on the superman sequences and the bloody Merovingian...
Thursday, May 29, 2003
Free speech?
Over on the other side of the pond Doc is all up in arms about plans to deregulate the media. The (increasingly political) Register have an even more extreme point of view.Wednesday, May 28, 2003
Class war part 32456983
The news that the number of state school pupils coming to Oxford is down this year is sure to hit the headlines again. I've got a few comments on this...With students already being forced to pay more for their education and carry more debt, wouldn't you expect a migration away from one of the most expensive cities in the UK? Starting with those least able to pay? You can trade in three years of Oxford and brideshead revisited for three years of Manchester, Liverpool, Newcastle or Birmingham - party towns with respected universities, and rents that are between 40 and 60% of the Oxford ones.
There is still no evidence that the Oxford selection process for undergraduates is biased in any way about anything. It turns out that if 40% of acceptances are from state schools its because so were 40% of applications, the same goes for women, ethnic minorities, disabled, left wing, right wing... you get the idea. The problem is all in the image.
When the chancellor of the exchequer picks a fight with the university on the grounds that its elitist what people remember is just that. Never mind that he was wrong about that and pretty much everything else he said at the time.
Straight outta the Matrix
Since Tad and Lucky had both taken this quiz I thought I'd give it a go and what do I get?Neo
So was it told about the long dark coat, shaved head and sunglasses, or did it just know? And all that time I wanted to be Morpheus.
Tuesday, May 27, 2003
Case teaching
Case teaching at Oxford is a bit of an odd affair. Actually working through a case, start to finish is a bit of an oddity. More often they become topics for discussion, pulled in to illustrate points or show theory being put into practice. It's certainly only the guest lecturers who turn them into the centrepiece of any given lecture.Today we had a visiting lecturer from LBS, formerly at Wharton and possibly Harvard (I forget) who took us through the Snapple case, on which he is apparently some kind of expert. Now, give the man his due it was entertaining stuff. He was lively, animated, and opinionated. He wrote things on the board and ploughed relentlessly through his notes, he had a gameplan for the next hour and he was not to be deflected. Questions rained down on the class, we quickly realised that all the answers were written on the pages of the case, look at the page, read something off and hey presto, you're in the good books. Hardly any need to think at all.
Post case though and I'm sitting here wondering what I learned. One hour of case study later here is what was taught
1. Market research is a useful starting point when branding a product
2. Most brands get started by accident
3. Its not about brands, its always about a Brand
To take these one at a time I've rarely seen a company that couldn't produce market research to explain it's latest dumb idea, and there was no discussion of what makes research good, bad or indifferent, of the kind of questions you should ask or the manner in which you should interpret the results. Just a maxim, research is good. In fact research often just tells you that what consumers want today they'll want again tomorrow. Not exactly groundbreaking stuff.
While many entrepreneurs do indeed end up with a brand largely by accident. (a powerbrand in this case) plenty of people plan brands very deliberately. Dr Peppers' Raging Cow, Hutchinson Whampoas' 3 and Mercedes / Swatches' Smart Car all spring to mind as recent examples.
The last point is just a nice bit of rhetoric. The case study method, good way to pass the time or intellectually stimulating? Discuss.
Monday, May 26, 2003
Ethical oil?
I'm currently drafting the first couple of sections for my groups project on corporate responsibility. We're supposed to prepare a corporate responsibility plan, a set of implementation recommendations and a description of likely opposition to our ideas and way for overcoming this. My group has chosen to prepare a piece on an oil company, currently going by the name of Exoff.This is a fairly tricky thing to do. Framing general principles in a manner that means they can't be twisted out of all recognition, but still retain some tangible meaning is hard going. Slightly harder going though is doing this for real. One member of the group worked with a major oil company in China and outlined a series of dilemmas for us that made it easy to see just how easy it is for companies to give into the temptation to do something wrong and why western companies may well feel like their ethical ideals hold them back in developing (and under-regulated markets).
Could be worse though. You could be the British Home Secretary, trying to fight back the overwhelming temptation to introduce ID cards and pander to the knee jerk xenophobia of the 'Great' British Public.
About time too
Looks like US lawmakers are planning to crack down on spam. While this is a good thing in itself I imagine it won't be long before spammers relocate to less well governed nations. Of course if top level ISP's would get their act together and crack down on this we could probably cut the spam problem in half in a matter of months, but as long as there's money in bandwidth...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)